Where The Best Minds Meet
 
Home | Everything | News | Blogs | Jobs | Ask Questions | Submit Article or Question | About Biharscoop | Register

Login

Make a new account

Username:
Password:

Who's Online? (8)

. Unregistered Visitors (8)

Note: You may cloak yourself from appearing here in your Display Preferences.

Recent Comments

. Looking for Investment in Bihar (bhishm4u)

. mungur (khyrahTakooree)

. This is the fact (Rajesh Kumar)

. Investment in Bihar (abhishekpandey)

. Investment in Bihar (abhishekpandey)

. About strikes of govt. Doctors in Bihar (abhishekpandey)

. problems are there. The challenge is to fix them (kanhaiya)

. Investment in Bihar (Dangi)

. My Experince Till date with Investment in Bihar (SUNNY)

. Investment in Bihar (bachapan)

Recent Member Diaries

Please Don't think in a different way always
by Rajesh Kumar - December 13

How to use the "Free Member Diaries" feature.
by Rajesh Kumar - August 20


More Diaries...

Front Page

Monday July 14th
. 'Free Health Camps In Each And Every District In The State': Paswan (0 comments)
. Governor urged to agree to strikers' demands (0 comments)
. Rly Introduced A Comprehensive Monsoon Safety Plan For Danapur Division Of East Central Railway (0 comments)
. Data Cell All Set To Hasten Ranchi University (RU) Results (0 comments)
. Hemophilia Test Camp Inaugurated at Patna Hospital (0 comments)
. RJD MPs From Bihar And Jharkhnad Summoned To Delhi For Special Parliament Session (0 comments)

Sunday July 13th
. Patna Law College, A Constituent Unit Of Patna University (PU) Faces Derecognition (0 comments)

Saturday July 12th
. New medical colleges coming up in Bihar - Union Health Minister Anbumani Ramadoss (0 comments)

Friday July 11th
. NABARD Loan Of Rs 235.50 Crore For Bridge Over Gandak In Gopalganj (0 comments)
. Two Bihar Builders Nutan Construction And Vasundhara Homes Fall InIncome Tax Net (0 comments)

Thursday July 10th
. Bihar Villagers Constructed A Dam To Prevent Floodwaters From Devastating Their Village (0 comments)
. Lalu Yadav Inaugurates Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) Regional Office (0 comments)

Wednesday July 9th
. Buddhist Monument In A Dilapidated Condition In Bihar,It Being Under Control Of Archaeological Deptt (0 comments)
. Bihar, Jharkhand Told To Meet Over 'Dues' For Education of Bihari Students At BIT, Sindri: Patna HC (0 comments)
. Bihar State Electricity Board (BSEB) For Increase The existing Power Tariff In Bihar (0 comments)
. Medical Council of India (MCI) Refuses To Increase Intake Of Students In PMCH, SKMCH (0 comments)
. L&T Bags Rs1,047.60cr Contract From Rlys For Setting Up Steel Wheel Manufacturing Plant In Bihar (0 comments)
. Education infrastructure in Bihar not meeting standards says Hamid Ansar (0 comments)

Tuesday July 8th
. New job-training program aims to improve lot of India's eunuchs (0 comments)

Monday July 7th
. Medical Council of India Declares Patna Medical College and Hospital Radiotherapy Degree Useless (0 comments)
. Independent Groups to Monitor Progress in MCDs (0 comments)
. Global Players In Race For Multi-Crore Electric Loco Project at Madhepura in Bihar (0 comments)
. Keventer Plans To Investing Rs 30cr Over The Next 2 Years To Set Up Banana Processing Unit In Bihar (0 comments)
. Indian Railways Decide To Accept Madrassa Degree Valid For Railway Jobs, says Lalu Prasad (0 comments)
. Madrassa degree valid for railway jobs, says Lalu Prasad (0 comments)

Friday July 4th
. Major Power Crisis Grips City, A Technical Snag In "Power Braker" (220 kV) At Fatuha (0 comments)
. RPG Group To Set Up Thermal Power Plant At Pirpainty In Bhagalpur District of Bihar (0 comments)
. Modi Calls For New National Bio-Fuel Policy And Set Up National Bio-Fuel Board (0 comments)
. Indian IT And ITES Sector On The Rise (0 comments)
. Count Your Calories On Sarkari Web Sites Now "www.healthy-india.org" (0 comments)

Older Stories...

New IIT Admission Policy Unfair

by Upendra Prasad
www.patnadaily.com
September 16, 2005
-------------------------------------------------
The new IIT entrance system which has recently been proposed by the HRD after the recommendation from the IITs will hurt the students from Bihar and Jharkhand Intermediate badly. The new system allows each student to sit only twice for the entrance, once in the year of writing the 12th standard exam and the year following. Also, there is a cut off of 60% in +12 marks as eligibility criteria.

The main reason that I would like to draw your attention to is the lack or total absence of a good educational system in the Bihar and Jharkhand Intermediate Council. We have lecturers in the colleges (+12 is associated with colleges in the intermediate system) who don't teach. They get a salary of Rs. 12,000 - 18,000 but hardly show their faces to the students. Take for example the Patna Science College. There was a time when this used to be one of the best science colleges in the country. What is left now is a complete mess. These schools and colleges can't even prepare their students for the usual +12 exam leave alone IIT entrance. If this is the state of the colleges in cities one can imagine the state of affairs of those in small towns.

A students when carves his way out from such bad educational environment needs time to get their basics of the subject. One year is the minimum that could be expected from students from villages and small town to finish the whole syllabus just once. Then they have to practice more and get a good understanding. Being an IIT graduate myself I would
suggest that a laborious, better-than-average student should have at least two chances after +12. Alas! the new system permits only one chance. The logic they give for this is beyond my comprehension. They say it would reduce exam stress and would deter the spread and influence of coaching institutes. Would it? In my opinion it would rather increase exam stress as there is only one shot left after +12 and in no way would be able to stop the Coaching Institutes exploit the students.

The most basic question is "exactly what the problem is that we are trying to solve". Is it the examination process that was so wrong that we need such a drastic change or the spread of coaching institutes? Most of the people that are familiar with the IIT Joint Entrance Exam would agree that it has possibly been the best way to select students for IIT.
Minor changes in due course are but natural in the process. As far as the mushrooming of coaching institutes is concerned, such a step would only encourage their demand in +12 and even in 10th standard. So, what the new system might be intending to do could just be described as the cure of a patient not the disease. What is ailing the education system is not the coaching institutes but the lackadaisical attitude of the government, teachers and worst of all the students and their parents. No one wants to raise his or her voice and complain or fight for our very basic right.

The other big change is the eligibility criteria of 60%. It is relatively easy to get 60% in CBSE and ICSE boards for any average student. But in Bihar and Jharkhand intermediate exams, given they are held fair and no large scale rigging takes place, it is really difficult. So we should not have the same criteria for all the boards. The JEE in itself is the best judge, why keep an eligibility criteria that would work against the underprivileged students.

So I exhort everyone specially the IITian from Bihar and Jharkhand to request the HRD to reconsider the matter in the interest of the students who come from not so good educational background.

By BiharBrains, Section Biharbrains Community
Posted on Mon Sep 26, 2005 at 06:03:58 AM EST
< BB MOM korea meet on sept 25,2005 | Scientific temper and the argumentative Indian >

Biharbrains Community
In search of Brains of Bihar
info@biharbrains.org
www.biharbrains.org biharbrains -subscribe@yahoogroups.com