Where The Best Minds Meet
 
Home | Everything | News | Blogs | Jobs | Ask Questions | Submit Article or Question | About Biharscoop | Register

Login

Make a new account

Username:
Password:
www.thejamalpur.com

Who's Online? (11)

. Unregistered Visitors (11)

Note: You may cloak yourself from appearing here in your Display Preferences.

Recent Comments

. Rules are only for the subjects and not for Rulers (Bihar Putra)

. Re: (outdoorh)

. Re: (09009)

. Investment in Bihar (achauhan2002)

. reforming bihar (rohitneta)

. Looking for Investment in Bihar (bhishm4u)

. mungur (khyrahTakooree)

. This is the fact (Rajesh Kumar)

. Investment in Bihar (abhishekpandey)

. Investment in Bihar (abhishekpandey)

Recent Member Diaries

Please Don't think in a different way always
by Rajesh Kumar - December 13

How to use the "Free Member Diaries" feature.
by Rajesh Kumar - August 20


More Diaries...

Front Page

Monday February 22nd
. Slim Chance For Early Polls In State (0 comments)
. Bihar To Work For The Settlement Of Nomadic Tribes (0 comments)

Sunday February 21st
. Bihar's Economic Miracle: Real, But Fragile (0 comments)
. Excise Dept Targets Rs 100cr Addl Revenue (0 comments)
. 11 Power Plant Proposals Okayed (0 comments)
. 200 Posts Lying Vacant In Medical Colleges (0 comments)

Friday February 19th
. Japan Keen To Invest In Bihar's Buddhist Circuit (0 comments)
. CCS Approves Opening Of Army's Second Officers Training Academy In Gaya (0 comments)
. Bihar Govt Inreases Ex-Gratia Payment (0 comments)
. Nalanda To Be Developed As Tourist Hub (0 comments)

Tuesday February 16th
. Governance: RTI, Mum's The Word, The Centre Plans To Manacle The RTI Act (0 comments)

Sunday February 14th
. Online RTI Applications For NRIs! (0 comments)

Friday February 12th
. Bihar To Set Up Farmer Information Centres With Toll Free Numbers (0 comments)
. Fresh Rules To Discipline State Govt Employees (0 comments)
. Bihar PCC May be Reconstituted (0 comments)
. IIT Patna Gets Land (0 comments)

Wednesday February 10th
. Bihar Mulls Bill To Rein In Private Coaching Centres (0 comments)
. Special Courts For Corruption Cases In Bihar (0 comments)

Tuesday February 9th
. Bihari Youth To Develop Course Curriculum For US Varsities (0 comments)
. AMU's Special Centre In Bihar On Fast Track (0 comments)
. Season Of Hope For Congress In Bihar (0 comments)
. Low-Cost Ranchi IIM To Start In June (0 comments)

Monday February 8th
. Several Bridges In Critical Stage (0 comments)
. Why You Will Have To Live With SMS Ads (0 comments)

Sunday February 7th
. Bihar Seeks Reimbursement Of Amount Spent On National Highways (0 comments)
. Bihar CM For Centralised Procurement Of Arms, Ammunition (0 comments)
. India To Launch Helpline For Tourists (0 comments)

Friday February 5th
. Land Distribution In Bihar Highly Polarized: Report (0 comments)
. Revisiting Traditional Irrigation System May Solve Bihar's Agricultural Problems (0 comments)
. Non-Resident Indian (NRI) Resumes Pile Up At Indian Human Resources (HR) Firms (0 comments)

Older Stories...

Bihar's Development: A Miracle Of GDP Numbers

Bookmark to: Linkarena Bookmark to: Digg Bookmark to: Facebook Bookmark to: Reddit Bookmark to: StumbleUpon Bookmark to: Furl Bookmark to: Spurl Bookmark to: Google Bookmark to: Technorati Bookmark to: Newsvine Bookmark to: Blinkbits Bookmark to: Netvouz Information
What seems to be happening is that the Bihar government has been successful in mobilizing funds, largely from the Centre, to spend on the creation of infrastructure

Bihar's economy is apparently a miracle, with its gross domestic product (GDP) growing by 11.44% in 2008-09, according to the statistics made available by the state's Directorate of Economics and Statistics, and reproduced on the website of the Central Statistical Organisation (CSO). That's not all. The state's GDP at constant (1999-2000) prices also increased by 22% in 2006-07 and by 8% in 2007-08, according to the same source. Is this growth for real? Has the Nitish Kumar government actually done wonders for the state?

For starters, let's take a look at the economic survey of the Government of Bihar for 2008-09. The chart shows the difference in growth rates for the state (GDP at constant prices, 1999-2000 base) as mentioned in the state government's economic survey and as reported on the CSO website. The growth rates were identical or nearly so between 2000-01 and 2003-04. From 2004-05, however, the rates of growth in the two sources are very different. It's very probable, of course, that the data for 2007-08 and the estimates for 2008-09 have been revised, although the difference between the economic survey's estimates for 2007-08 and 2008-09, and the figures they have furnished to CSO is glaring. But surely, the numbers for 2004-05 and 2005-06 should be similar? The absolute numbers for the state GDP given in the economic survey and those furnished to the CSO show inconsistencies. These discrepancies cast severe doubt on the state's data.

Manas Chakravarty takes a weekly look at trends and issues in the financial markets.

Source: Live Mint By Manas Chakravarty Bihar's development: a miracle of GDP numbers

Click on "Full Story" For More...

By ugesh sarkar, Section Development In Bihar
Posted on Tue Jan 26, 2010 at 10:13:59 PM EST
Let's look at other, more reliable indicators of the state's prosperity. Data taken from the Reserve Bank of India show that Bihar's share of bank deposits was 2.2% in September 2005, while its share of bank credit, an indicator of the growth of business, was 0.9%. After four years of the Nitish Kumar government, in September, Bihar's share of all-India deposits was the same at 2.2%, and even its share of bank credit had not budged, at 0.9%. If indeed growth in Bihar during the last four years has been above the all-India average, that hasn't been fuelled by bank credit, nor has the resultant prosperity led to an increase in its share of bank deposits. Interestingly, the state's share of bank deposits was 2.8% in March 2001, implying a rapid deterioration in the state during 2001-05, which was presumably one of the reasons for the big victory for Nitish Kumar. The numbers show he has been able to stop that decline.

What about the quality of growth? The state government's economic survey for 2008-09 says that the construction sector grew by 23.3% in 2004-05, a huge 83.58% in 2005-06 and 30.2% in 2006-07 and it estimated that growth in the sector would be 43.85% in 2008-09. That ties in neatly with the rising cement off-take in the state. The December data, for instance, show that Bihar tops the cement consumption list for the country, with an annual growth rate of 36%. It also supports anecdotal evidence of a large number of bridges and other public works being constructed. According to the state's figures, construction now contributes 13.4% of the state's GDP compared with 4.2% in 2003-04. The other sectors that did well are manufacturing, communications, trade and hospitality. The share of agriculture in the economy has been declining, but floods and droughts impart great volatility to the state's growth numbers.

Much of the money for the public works is being given by the Union government. The state's economic survey says, "For Bihar, this dependency on the Central government for meeting its expenditure needs is very high. From around 40% in 2003-04, this ratio (ratio of gross transfers from the Central government to aggregate expenditure) has increased steadily to as much as 72% in last two years, indicating an overwhelming dependence of the state on the Central government." The survey shows that, in addition to the state's share of divisible taxes from the Centre, grants-in-aid have increased from 13% of total expenditure in 2003-04 to 26% in 2008-09. For instance, under the Indira Awaas Yojana for rural housing, the allocation for Bihar for 2009-10 is the highest among the states, at Rs3,043 crore. So far the percentage of utilization of funds has been 67%, around the all-India average of 68%. But the larger allocation means a lot more money going into rural housing in Bihar.

What seems to be happening is that the Bihar government has been successful in mobilizing funds, largely from the Centre, to spend on the creation of infrastructure. Whether that will result in the shift of industries to the state is anybody's guess--manufacturing constituted 5.45% of the state's economy in 2008-09, according to the state's economic survey, compared with 5.63% in 2003-04. Relying on the state's data to rush to any conclusion would call for a heroic leap of faith.

< Bihar Govt. To Fill Ten Thousand Non-Gazetted Posts | Bihar Villagers Construct Wooden Bridge Instead of Waiting for Govt. To Help >

Biharbrains Community
In search of Brains of Bihar
info@biharbrains.org
www.biharbrains.org biharbrains -subscribe@yahoogroups.com